WASHINGTON - The US Supreme Court Tuesday ruled the government has the right to fine broadcasters for profanity on television.
But the 5-4 decision left open whether a ban on expletives by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) constitutes a violation of free speech, likely sending the case back down to a lower court.
US television networks FOX, ABC, CBS and NBC had challenged whether the government had the jurisdiction to hand down fines of up to $325,000 for ‘fleeting expletives’ on live television broadcasts.
The Supreme Court ruled in favour of the FCC, but Justice Antonin Scalia made clear that the court was only ruling on whether the government’s ban was ‘arbitrary and capricious’.
It left open the wider issue of whether the ban should be struck down because of free-speech guarantees in the US constitution. The Supreme Court said it was up to a lower court to address that larger question first.
Filed under Americas, Court, News | Tags: Washington | Comment Below
Related?
North Dakota Supreme Court upholds probe of Internet service provider's marketing practicesMay 8th, 2009 ND Supreme Court upholds Internet provider probeBISMARCK, N.D. — North Dakota's Supreme Court says the attorney general may continue a probe into the marketing practices of an Internet service provider.
Germany's highest court upholds ban on triple-barrelled surnamesMay 5th, 2009 Germany upholds triple-barrelled name banBERLIN — Germany's highest court ruled Tuesday that a married couple — Ms. Thalheim and Mr.
Supreme Court upholds Calcutta HC order on banning old vehicles in WBJuly 31st, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Supreme Court on Monday refused to stay the order of the Calcutta High Court order banning commercial vehicles which are 15-year-old and more in the city. The order means that the ban on the vehicles will continue.
Supreme Court upholds new recruitment in Nepal ArmyMarch 14th, 2009 KATHMANDU - The Supreme Court (SC) of Nepal on Friday upheld the fresh recruitments of around 3,000 soldiers in the Nepal Army (NA). The apex court announced that the new recruits should not be stopped as they have already received appointment letters.
Supreme Court upholds Karnataka order on power tariffApril 13th, 2009 BANGALORE - The Supreme Court Monday upheld the Karnataka government order, directing power producers such as GMR Energy to supply electricity to the state grid at Rs.5.50 per unit as fixed January 1, an official said. 'The apex court dismissed a special leave petition (SLP) filed by GMR Energy challenging the tariff order, which was issued to ensure all power producers supply power to the state grid to ease the acute power shortage in the state,' state energy department principal secretary K.
Supreme Court upholds permit to dump waste from Alaska gold mine into lakeJune 22nd, 2009 Court OKs dumping gold mine waste in lakeWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has upheld a federal government permit to dump waste from an Alaskan gold mine into a nearby lake, even though all its fish would be killed. By a 6-3 vote Monday, the justices say a federal appeals court wrongly blocked the permit on environmental grounds.
Calif. high court upholds death sentence for man convicted in 1993 of murdering of Polly KlaasJune 1st, 2009 Polly Klaas killer to remain on Calif. death rowSAN FRANCISCO — The California high court has upheld the death sentence of the man convicted of kidnapping and killing 12-year-old Polly Klaas in 1993.
Court upholds Ohio officer's conviction in killings of girlfriend and their unborn daughterJuly 22nd, 2009 Ohio officer's murder conviction upheldCANTON, Ohio — A state appeals court has upheld an Ohio police officer's conviction in the deaths of his pregnant girlfriend and their unborn daughter. Attorneys for Bobby Cutts Jr.
